Subscribe to our blog
Get ahead with our award-winning insights on the latest developments in the fraud and compliance landscape. Enter your email below to receive our blog posts directly to your inbox.

Post Written by

In one of our recent webinars, Sarah Hody, of the law firm Perkins Coie stated that “If a token is administrating or exchanging virtual currencies, FinCEN could deem the ICO issuer a money transmitter, which would require them to be registered under the federal BSA guidelines.”

Well, FinCEN recently revealed a letter where they state that they consider non-security ICOs as Money Service Businesses (MSBs) per previous FinCEN guidance.

Why would they make this determination?

If a company exchanges a virtual currency for another currency, virtual or otherwise, then the company is an MSB. That is, they are offering services to exchange a currency of one value for a different currency that also has value. A company conducting an ICO is issuing and exchanging their token with a different virtual currently. This is not unlike converting from US Dollars to Euros.

What does this mean?

All ICOs that are not registered securities must now:

  • Register with FinCEN as a money transmitter
  • Register with each US state that requires a Money Transmission License. (This is just for the ICO).
  • Comply with regulations pertaining to money transmission, such as having a risk-based Know Your Customer (KYC) process in place

State licenses for MSBs take two years and several million dollars, on average. It is unlikely that a company conducting an ICO is going to do this.

Here’s what we recommend:

  • Working with firms like Tokensoft or Securitize that can help you launch a security instead of an utility token. In the meantime, learning about exceptions such as Reg A+ and Reg S.
  • Blocking US contributors. IdentityMind helps companies block US contributors by looking at IP, Device, Address and Documents. 
  • Have a good lawyer. Our clients and partners have spoken highly about these firms: Marc Boiron at Fisher Broyles (securities) and Kathryn Graham, Esq. (MSB).

IdentityMind for Token Sales

What’s next?

  • This regulation impacts all companies conducting an ICO in the US or to US contributors.
  • The last time FinCEN got involved, it brought a civil enforcement action against Ripple for not complying for 60 days.

This may mean the end for utility tokens in the United States. It’s hard to imagine that releasing a letter to a Senator can do that, but FinCEN does have the authority. Likely the next course of action is a lawsuit against a company who had a large ICO to show that they are serious and to send a message to other companies.